Why Converting an Unincorporated Charity Preschool to a CIO Makes Sense

 A Practical Guide for Early Years Providers

For many early years and childcare settings, especially long-established pre-schools and playgroups, being an unincorporated charitable association has always been the traditional structure. It’s simple, familiar, and historically worked well for small community groups run by volunteers.

But as the sector evolves—and responsibilities for safe practice, governance, employment, and financial management grow—more providers are finding that their current legal structure no longer gives them the protection or flexibility they need.

This is why many pre-schools registered with the Charity Commission are choosing to convert to a Charitable Incorporated Organisation (CIO).

Below, I explore the key advantages of becoming a CIO and why it may be one of the most beneficial long-term decisions for your early years setting.

1. Limited Liability—Protection for Trustees and Volunteers

Perhaps the biggest advantage of a CIO is the introduction of limited liability.

In an unincorporated charity:

• Trustees can be personally liable for debts, contractual obligations, or claims.

• This applies even when trustees have acted in good faith.

For early years providers—who manage staff, buildings, leases, safeguarding responsibilities, and funding—this creates significant risk.

In a CIO:

• The charity itself, not the trustees, enters into contracts.

• Trustees have limited personal liability, offering peace of mind.

• It becomes much easier to recruit and retain trustees when they know they are protected.

For pre-schools that employ staff, manage premises, or run fundraising events, this protection is invaluable.

---

2. A CIO Is a Legal Entity That Can Enter Contracts in Its Own Name

Unincorporated associations cannot:

• Employ staff in their own name

• Hold property or leases

• Enter into contracts independently

This often causes administrative complexity and legal vulnerability.

A CIO, on the other hand:

• Can sign a lease directly

• Employ staff as the legal employer

• Enter into funding agreements

• Own assets

This simplifies life for early years providers, particularly when dealing with:

• Local authorities

• Landlords or parish councils

• Insurance companies

• Grant funders

It also prevents trustees’ personal details being tied to legal documentation such as building leases or service contracts.

---

3. More Professional Governance and Operational Stability

Many pre-schools are heavily reliant on the commitment of individual volunteers. While this community-based model is still at the heart of the early years sector, it can create instability when committees turn over each year.

A CIO helps create long-term continuity, because:

• Governance responsibilities are clearer.

• Processes are simplified.

• The charity becomes more robust and less vulnerable to committee changes.

This is particularly helpful for settings where parent-run committees change frequently, causing loss of knowledge or inconsistency in management.

---

4. Simplified Regulation—Only One Regulator

Unlike charitable companies, which must report to Companies House AND the Charity Commission, a CIO reports only to the Charity Commission.

This means:

• One annual return

• One set of accounts

• One regulator to deal with

For busy managers and volunteer trustees, this reduces administrative load and simplifies compliance.

---

5. Better Access to Grants and Funding

Many funders prefer to support incorporated charities because they:

• Demonstrate stronger governance

• Show greater financial accountability

• Offer more security for funders

Some grant makers now specifically require incorporation before awarding funds for capital projects, building improvements, or community-based initiatives.

For pre-schools that rely on grants to improve their environment or expand services, becoming a CIO can open doors.

---

6. More Modern and Flexible Constitution Options

CIOs are designed with modern charities in mind.

You can choose between:

• Foundation CIO model – trustees are the only voting members

• Association CIO model – wider membership plus trustees

The CIO constitution provides:

• Clear decision-making processes

• Structured governance

• Improved safeguarding of assets

• Less ambiguity in roles and responsibilities

This helps childcare providers demonstrate strong leadership and management—something Ofsted inspectors also recognise.

---

7. Easier to Recruit Trustees and Committee Members

One of the biggest challenges for early years settings—especially committee-run preschools—is finding volunteers willing to become trustees.

When individuals know they will not be personally liable for employment issues, leases, or financial risks, they are far more willing to join.

CIO status:

• Reduces fear of legal exposure

• Makes roles more attractive

• Promotes stronger leadership structures

This directly supports long-term sustainability for provider settings.

---

8. Long-Term Stability for the Pre-school’s Future

Incorporation helps ensure that the pre-school:

• Has a clear legal identity

• Is protected during trustee turnover

• Can grow or adapt more easily

• Has stronger governance foundations

For many early years providers, becoming a CIO is a step toward securing the organisation for future generations of children and families in the community.

---

Final Thoughts

For unincorporated early years and childcare charities, converting to a CIO offers numerous advantages—most importantly, protection for trustees, improved governance, legal clarity, and long-term stability.

While the conversion process requires planning and time, the benefits far outweigh the administrative effort. As responsibilities increase and expectations in the early years sector continue to rise, operating as a CIO creates a safer, more resilient, and future-ready structure.

Want to know more about becoming a CIO? Book a Discovery Call and let's have a chat.

BOOK A DISCOVERY CALL HERE